I just finished reading The Assault on Reason and have a few thoughts to share. Although I think that Al Gore is right that the current pathetic state of "news" on TV is partly to blame for the current woes of America, I think that there is a far bigger cause: the erosion of the Constitution.
Here's why:
The founding fathers understood very well that no matter how good or well-intentioned a particular president or political party may seem, basic human weaknesses like greed, jealousy, close-mindedness or short-sightedness can lead a country to ruin. So they decided to run the US with "a government of laws, not men", which meant that the country had to uniformly abide by its laws regardless of which particular group of people were in power. They wrote the US constitution hoping that its initial set of laws would protect the country from some of the worst excesses the founders had seen in other governments.
Unfortunately, their plan has gone wrong and we are currently experiencing some of the results.
In my opinion, the single most devastating misinterpretation of the constitution is regarding Article 1, Section 8, which says:
The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States;
When the founding fathers wrote this paragraph, the phrase "general welfare of the United States" meant that the federal goverment would assist individual states in a time of natural disaster or domestic violence. It did not mean providing welfare for the average citizen.
If you don't believe me, read this article, which not only supplies a dictionary definition of the phrase for the time the constitution was written, but also includes a copy of a letter by James Madison, the President of the United States, vetoing a bill to spend federal money on road systems because it would violate the US constitution.
The effect of misintepreting this single phrase has led to a huge expansion of the federal government, which continues to grow and consume more tax dollars as it finds more ways to "provide for general welfare". The government then uses this tax money to buy votes through campaign promises, channel money into special interests, and force its ideology onto states via the threat of withholding federal funds.
The main point here is that the founding fathers knew the problems associated with unchecked federal government growth, and specifically protected the country against it by limiting the power of the federal government in Article 1, section 8. Unfortunately, the DNA of the country has been badly damaged and now the founding fathers worst fears are coming true.
I don't know if it's possible to repair such profound damage to the nation's DNA. It would be great if someone like Ron Paul was elected to become president, because he's the one candidate that stands out as truly understanding and respecting the original constitution.
Recent Comments